Easy Homemade Yogurt

Name: Easy Homemade Yogurt
Prep time: 5 min
Cook time: 10 min
Total time: 15 min
Ingredients: 1 gallon of whole milk; 2 cups of plain full-fat yogurt

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

This homemade yogurt recipe is simple and easy using two ingredients: a starter yogurt and milk. This recipe doesn't need any fancy gadgets, just a stovetop pot with a cover and towel. Use your homemade yogurt for a labneh dip, mint and cucumber yogurt, or kibbeh labanieh.

yogurt in a pot on the counter next to a napkin

What I Love About This Recipe

This homemade yogurt recipe is failure-proof and it's the easiest, simplest way to make homemade yogurt. My family makes a big batch of homemade yogurt every two weeks. We keep half of the yogurt to make labneh dip, and then we use the other half of the yogurt in other recipes like a peach yogurt smoothie, chicken biryani, or served alongside baked stuffed kibbeh.

Ingredients

Whole milk: Use whole milk for creamy homemade yogurt. I prefer grassfed organic milk.
Plain full-fat yogurt: Use unsweetened plain full-fat cow's milk yogurt. Plain yogurt is different from Greek yogurt, and I recommend using plain yogurt.

See the recipe card at the bottom of the post for quantities.

How to Make Homemade Yogurt

Add the milk to the stovetop pot on high heat.

Bring the milk to a boil, then turn off the stove.

Pro Tip: Monitor the milk closely so the milk doesn't boil over.

Allow the milk to cool down until you can hold your (clean) finger in the milk for 10 seconds. Skim the film off of the milk.

grab some milk to add to the starter yogurt

Scoop two cups of milk and mix with two cups of starter yogurt.

Whisk the starter yogurt and milk together until smooth in a separate bowl.

Add the yogurt and milk mixture back to the milk.

Cover the milk with the pot cover and wrap it in a towel.

Let the yogurt sit covered for 24 hours at room temperature. If you would like sour yogurt, allow the yogurt to sit covered for 48 hours at room temperature.

The yogurt may have more whey than store-bought yogurt which is normal. If you would like to thicken up the yogurt, strain the yogurt using a thin cotton cloth or kitchen sack towel.

The yogurt may look bumpy or curdled. It's optional to use a whisk to smooth it out. Store the yogurt in the fridge for up to 2 weeks.

Tips and Tricks

Watch the milk while it boils. It's very easy for milk to boil over and make a mess, so it's best to watch the milk while you bring it to a boil.
Keep the yogurt wrapped in a towel. The yogurt needs a warm room temperature environment.
Use organic, grassfed milk for the best-tasting yogurt.

Substitutions and Variations

Use 2% milk, fat-free milk, or goat milk in lieu of whole milk. The yogurt consistency will be different for 2% milk and fat-free milk (less thick).
This method uses live yogurt cultures from a starter yogurt, however, yogurt can be made with a freeze-dried yogurt starter.

Equipment

Use a large stovetop pot with a lid to boil and store the yogurt. Wrap the stovetop pot in a towel to keep the yogurt warm while resting at room temperature.

Storage

Store the homemade yogurt in an airtight container in the fridge for about two weeks.

FAQs

Can yogurt be made at home?

Yes, yogurt can be made at home with basic kitchen tools: a stovetop pot, cover, and towel.

How do I make homemade yogurt?

Make homemade yogurt by bringing milk to a boil. Allow the milk to cool down to the point you can stick your finger in it for 10 seconds. Add the starter yogurt and mix. Cover the stovetop pot and wrap it with a towel. Let the yogurt form at room temperature for between 24 hours and 48 hours.

Is making homemade yogurt worth it?

It depends on how much yogurt you need. You can make one gallon of yogurt for the cost of one gallon of milk.

Yogurt Recipes

Join the Tribe

Subscribe to The Matbakh Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, or Pinterest pages. We also have a saucy newsletter.